After four separate incidents of a certain phenomenon I begin to doubt my own experience is that unique. Excepting that I don’t hear others discussing this, I am convinced that perhaps the issues I have experienced are perhaps not that common. My problem is related to aromatics. Specifically, scented products sold commercially to add fragrance to the home.
My wife tells me I have a hyper-active sniffer. The fact I mentally catalog various smells and revel in pointing out similarities and differences is a bit tedious for her, of that I am sure. My love for identifying fragrances and flowers by smell is older than I can recall, and I am not aware of its origin. I just know I pay specific attention to the smell of things, and often associate certain smells with strong sense memories. The result is that I am very particular about those odors I consider to be my favorites.
This idiosyncrasy has not always been problematic for me. For instance I have a favorite incense variety (Gonesh #10, for the inquisitive) and it has remained atop my rankings for incense varieties since the mid-1990s when I burned my first stick on my bedroom windowsill on a cool, early-spring evening (there was nothing remarkably significant of the occasion, other than it demonstrates the peculiar way my brain links my sinus to my hippocampus).
My conundrum is this: I have on more than one occasion purchased some aroma therapy product which I have really enjoyed only to later find it completely unavailable for future purchase. Sure, you say, products come and go. Live on this great-big-rock for long enough and you’ll outlive some of them.
Manufacturers, in the interest of keeping their product line fresh will change things up from time to time. I can believe that, and even understand the reasoning behind such decisions. I have also considered the false scarcity principle (pulling a certain product line to increase interest in it – read: Disney movies) for keeping customers on their toes. What I cannot explain is how this disappearing act has happened to me with four different products, each from a unique manufacturer, each a different kind of air freshening device.
My first experience with a discontinued product was an essential oil blend from an alternative pharmacy in Coralville (just west of Iowa City) back around the turn of the millennium. NuCara pharmacy used to carry a line of aroma-therapy oils and my wife registered me for a “scent of the month” club for my birthday, whereby I was able to sample several different scent blends over a 12 month period. I found a tropical flower scented oil that I really enjoyed and purchased about 4 grams of it in a vial (in addition to the oils I received from the scent-of-the-month club, that’s how much I enjoyed it.) When that vial ran out (the oil burns slightly each time it is heated and must be discarded eventually) I went back to get more from the store only to find that they had phased out that scent. Of course no one could tell me why this scent was discontinued or if they would bring it back – I was just out of luck.
A few years later around Halloween time we found a black licorice scented candle at the local Yankee Candle store in the mall. It was called “Black Cat” or some other seasonally-related name, but it smelled fantastic. The scent was refreshingly clean and mysterious. We burned that candle judiciously over one year assuming we would stock up the following Halloween, only to discover that they discontinued that scent as well. We have checked rigorously year after year looking for that scent. Yankee Candle, a nation-wide purveyor of scented candles, had this to say about their decision to phase out certain scents from their lineup: “We like to keep our customers up to date with fresh scents on a regular basis. While we maintain certain favorites year-round, year after year, others we update, change or just retire from time to time.” No joy. We did find a helpful clerk at the store during one annual pilgrimage to their franchise who went into the storeroom to find us a Christmas-themed “Licorice Spice” candle that was equal parts anise and mint scented. Not quite what we were looking for, but the closest we’d come in some time.
While my wife tolerates my addiction to particular scents, she also acts as an enabler; for my birthday a few years ago she bought me a La-Tee-Da effusion oil lamp. This thing is fantastic from top-to-bottom, beginning-to-end. It is a glass lamp with a brass collar, fitted with a cotton wick connected to a stone effusion block. It functions as follows: you fill the artistic glass lamp with effusion oil (scented and flammable) and then you insert the wick and collar on top of the lamp. The wick transfers oil to the stone, which is porous and will ignite when exposed to an open flame. The stone remains lighted for a minute or two, and then when properly heated, you extinguish the flame and the heated stone continues to glow with heat and transfer odor-packed heated oil scent into the air.
To this day I haven’t found a better way to replace unwanted odors in our house, or a better way to “freshen up” the smell of a place. My wife bought me two different fragrances. I burned through the first one pretty quickly, but the second I have been savoring for the better part of the last 4-5 years.
La-Tee-Da confusingly applies two names to each of their fragrances (further confounding frustrated customer’s web searches when they discontinue a particular scent). The second scent my wife bought me is called “Grass Roots” or “Freshly Cut Clover,” and has a fresh, clean, meadow-like scent to it. It is pleasing and reminds me of our first years of marriage. I have tried over and over to find replacement bottles of this fragrance online, and I’ve tried to find a way to contact the company to see if they ever intend to manufacture that scent again, all to no avail.
Last, I have a favorite scent of Glade Plug-In oil refills; Jasmine and White Rose. It is NOT a discontinued scent, so for all intents and purposes it really doesn’t belong in this list. However, the availability of this scent in our local retail centers is sporadic at best. Glade, like other companies in the scent industry, has the same habit of trying out new scents and scent combinations, altering slightly the perfume bill on newer versions of older models, and discontinuing scents arbitrarily. I will say, however, that Glade does a good job sticking to some of their old standards. Jasmine and White Rose appears from time-to-time locally and is listed as a currently available scent on their web site, but due to it’s unreliable availability in our area I include it on this list.
This scent also has a personal significance to me because when our house was on the market and we first visited it, the realtor (or previous owner, not entirely sure on this) used this scent in the house. It is a clean and refreshing scent and not over-powering. I had forgotten about the scent until about three months ago when my wife came home from the store with some new Glade replacement cartridges When we plugged them in I was immediately aware that we had found the specific scent I remembered from when we bought our house, one I had searched for unsuccessfully on prior occasions.
My concern with these hard-to-find scents is the psychology of loss and grief; that I may have forever lost the ability to smell them ever again when they are discontinued. I know on a scale of world problems this one is not earth-shattering, but when you grow attached to something and it holds significance for you, it is troublesome to see a thing discontinued or capriciously modified for the sake of re-igniting a product line.
Part of me accepts defeat in losing these products with the understanding that if I ever smell those scents again someday, their memory will be far more powerful through extended absence than they ever could be with continued use. Another part of me wants to give up on commercially produced fragrances all together and develop my own sustainable fragrance line so I can recreate my own favorites whenever I like.
I suppose the moral of the story is to appreciate what you have when you have it, and appreciate the memory of it when it is gone. That, and if you like something enough, stock up on it; you may never see it in stores again.








